Butterfingers
Most turnovers in the regular season.
Given in each division. Awarded 89 times.
Most wins
- 2Unknown player
Winners by season
| Season | Winner |
|---|---|
| SPL 15 | Unknown player Ottawa Valley Slap Tuahs 61 Turnovers - 13 Games Played |
| SPL 14 | Adict Jersey City Grinders 53 Turnovers - 9 Games Played |
| SPL 12 | Unknown player Springfield Ice-O-Topes 88 Turnovers - 13 Games Played |
| SPL 11 | Inph1del Hartford Wolves 62 Turnovers - 17 Games Played |
| SPL 10 | AboveAverageJoe Ottawa Valley Puck Slappers 81 Turnovers - 14 Games Played |

