Butterfingers
Most turnovers in the regular season.
Given in each division. Awarded 89 times.
Most wins
Winners by season
| Season | Winner |
|---|---|
| SPL 16 | Tony Denver Cutthroats 56 Turnovers - 14 Games Played |
| SPL 15 | Walster Greene Goblins 69 Turnovers - 16 Games Played |
| SPL 14 | tmoneytom Toronto Terrors 93 Turnovers - 17 Games Played |
| SPL 13 | AboveAverageJoe Ottawa Valley Puck Slappers 72 Turnovers - 18 Games Played |
| SPL 12 | Dionysus Windy City Watchmen 99 Turnovers - 18 Games Played |
| SPL 11 | Dionysus Windy City Watchmen 100 Turnovers - 17 Games Played |
| SPL 10 | Rom West Virginia Orangutans 66 Turnovers - 12 Games Played |
| SPL 9 | KennyT Pittsburgh Spinners 85 Turnovers - 15 Games Played |
| SPL 8 | DatBoiiWadup 53 Turnovers - 13 Games Played |

