Butterfingers
Most turnovers in the regular season.
Given in each division. Awarded 89 times.
Most wins
- 2DarkArrow
Winners by season
| Season | Winner |
|---|---|
| SPL 16 | JoshAllenfan420 Buffalo Blizzards 108 Turnovers - 16 Games Played |
| SPL 15 | Deaner Bobcaygeon Catfish 62 Turnovers - 13 Games Played |
| SPL 14 | ATK Florida Rink Rats 82 Turnovers - 16 Games Played |
| SPL 13 | T1nyCreeper Weston Whoppers 59 Turnovers - 13 Games Played |
| SPL 12 | I'm Terrible Kentucky Fried Chickens 56 Turnovers - 11 Games Played |
| SPL 11 | Bueller New York City Knights 41 Turnovers - 10 Games Played |
| SPL 10 | Dos & madmax200721 Farnham Flame 46 Turnovers - 10 Games Played |
| SPL 9 | DarkArrow Lexington Bananas 57 Turnovers - 14 Games Played |
| SPL 8 | DarkArrow Lexington Bananas 52 Turnovers - 16 Games Played |

