Best Fit
Voted by the league. Awarded 12 times.
Most wins
Winners by season
| Season | Winner | Votes | Runner-up | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPL 22 | nutsack6 | 26 | EggsThink | 24 |
| SPL 21 | Reborn | 6 | kevin | 3 |
| SPL 20 | EggsThink | 22 | Reborn | 19 |
| SPL 19 | 9th Coming of Jesus | 16 | EggsThink | 15 |
| SPL 18 | Tee | 16 | LaffTrakk | 13 |
| SPL 17 | Dil | 22 | BroBurgota | 16 |
| SPL 16 | BroBurgota first ever 3-way tie Troy Bolton first ever 3-way tie EggsThink first ever 3-way tie | 15 | — | |
| SPL 15 | Kajun | 17 | Charles | 13 |
| SPL 14 | PoppaNut | 2 | Slippin' Johnny | 1 |
| SPL 12 | Milk & Slippin Johnny | 21 | bLue | 11 |
| SPL 11 | Milk | 22 | Slippin' Johnny | 18 |
| SPL 10 | Hex | 34 | Ungluedsnail | 17 |

