Poppa’s Mid-Season Challenger Power Rankings
By Poppanut · May 29, 2024
We are now well underway into season 13 of the Challenger Division, and well… my pre-season standings have been blown to pieces. The extremely unpredictable nature of the Challenger division has struck again, and now that roster lock has passed, it is time once again to gauge the current team standings. We had a few buzzer-beater signings that could make some serious waves, along with some rather interesting developments with a couple of my pre-season favorite teams. Let’s not dilly-dally and get straight to this edition of Poppa’s Chal Power Rankings!
Power Rankings
Tier 1: The Favorites
Ottawa Valley Puck Slappers
Pennsylvania Ball-Peen Hammers
The Puck Slappers are nearly unbeatable when they have both BroBurgota (soon to be the 4X) and AboveAverageJoe playing. While they don’t boast league-leading stats in any specific category, OVPS has the best 3rd-period/OT play of any team in this whole division. They’re 3-0 in OT games, and are incredibly solid fundamentally, rarely making costly mistakes in key situations. The Puck Slappers are going to be a tough out in any playoff series they come across. Next to them is one of only 2 teams to beat OVPS’s full-strength roster, the Ball-Peen Hammers. It’s really easy to see why they’re up here, as they exhibit the league's best defense, whilst also hosting great wins over nearly every other playoff team. My one worry with the Peen is the fact that they have yet to really blow out an opponent, as 7 of their 10 played games were decided by 2 or fewer goals. At this point, you could make serious arguments to replace the Peen with one of the below teams, but if they can manage a dominant and impressive win within the coming weeks, that would secure their place here (no I did not place them high just cause I joined them lmao).
Tier 2: The Playoff Locks
Coaticook Kingpins
Kentucky Karens
Portsmouth Pottymouths
A few new faces in the playoff lock category: the Karens, Kingpins, and Pottymouths have all risen to the occasion, all having serious cases for this season's dark horse award. The Karens, being the most surprising team here, have really benefitted from the addition of Jenediah, finally allowing them some consistency at the 3 position. Similar to the Peen, however, the Karens are allergic to blowouts, playing nearly half of their games to overtime (4-1 in OT games). The Kingpins, on the other hand, seem to struggle punching up in this division. They dominate the lower teams on this list but are 2-3 in games against teams above a .500 record. If the Kingpins want to finally make a run in the playoffs, they need to find a way to elevate their play to the quality opponents they’ll run into down the line. Finally, the Pottymouths have been on a dark horse-caliber run these past couple of weeks, coming into roster lock going 6-1 since their less-than-ideal start to the season. As long as they don’t have to play the Bassmasters come playoff time, the Pottymouths have a good chance at making a run. Their last matchup against OVPS, assuming BroBurgota plays, will be very telling about the true strength of this team.
Tier 3: The Dark Horses
Hot Springs Hot Tamales
Carolina Bassmasters
Hanover Ham Hoggers
Now for the kings of inconsistency; all 3 of these teams have the unfortunate quality of constantly playing down to their opponents, especially in the case of the Bassmasters. Sitting at 4-8 currently, the Bassmasters have dropped from kings of the division to the weekly punching bags. If this team would actually try, they’d be the scariest team in the division, but unless they have a change of heart, we’ll likely miss them come playoff time. The Ham Hoggers are somewhat similar, but more just have inconsistent play against top teams. On any given night, the full-strength Hoggers can beat anyone in this division, but they just can’t seem to decide on a lineup. As it stands, the Hoggers are poised to snag that 6th playoff spot, but I can very much see this team put together a solid last couple of weeks to move up in the rankings. Finally, the Hot Tamales have fallen off a cliff these past few weeks. After starting 3-1 with quality wins, the Hot Tamales have struggled to stay afloat. There is still hope, however, as they sit just 3 points out of playoffs with 1 less game played. If they can dig deep and pull together a couple of impressive wins, this could be a feisty 6th seed.
Tier 4: The Gutter
Quebec Flare of Cowtown
Los Angeles Comets
I will start by saying, the gutter has gotten significantly better since the last rankings. The comets, who were a part of my pre-season favorites (they had Laff, don’t make fun of me), have completely imploded and can’t seem to buy a win right now. It’s perplexing as well, seeing as they have a quality roster full of great up-and-coming players. If I had to put the blame on any specific reason for their lack of success, it would definitely come from the 3 position, as Vorq has only 10 assists and 143 passes in 8 games played (Young Buck eclipses these numbers). On to the Flare, they’ve actually put together quite a scrappy roster here at the roster deadline. The signings of Timmy and Voltzy make them at the very least interesting, but they will still struggle to find a single win this season. Good luck in IM next season, fellas!
*UPDATE*
Literally 15 seconds after I uploaded this, the Comets elected to disband, with Tweek receiving a captaincy ban. While there aren't any immediate consequences for the other teams, this does mean the Flare will receive their first win of the season, way to go guys! The resulting FFs boost the Ham Hogger up to 4th place, the Peen up to 1st, and drops the Puck slappers and Bassmasters both down 2 spots (3rd and 8th). This also brings the Hot Tamales within 1 point of playoffs, which will be an interesting storyline to follow.

