SPL Summer 2026 Ice Cream Frenzy Round 2
By EggsThink, Hammy, Sweatshirt and AboveAverageJoe · Jul 20, 2026
After a long week of voting, eight different flavors of ice cream have been eliminated from our bracket, starting today and lasting until July 26th, you guys will once again be voting to determine which four flavors move on to the Semi Finals.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough would beat out Coffee 15-2, I personally have never had coffee ice cream in my life and hate coffee, so this does not come as a surprise to me. Sorry to your old man flavors Joe.
Neapolitan would beat Peanut Butter 10-7 to advance to the next round, marking the first time Napoli has made it out of the first round in the playoffs in forever. Oops, wrong Neapolitans, nonetheless, I’m sure Sweatshirt is happy seeing as he is allergic to peanuts.
Vanilla, the all-time classic, beat Butter Pecan 11-6, I don’t have much to say, Vanilla is an all-star performer.
Cake Batter would beat Black Cherry 12-5. Unfortunately for me, Black Cherry is my favorite flavor, if you have not tried it, I recommend trying it. Cake Batter still slaps though.
Moose Tracks beat Mint Chocolate Chip 11-6, I haven’t had Mint Chocolate Chip since I was probably 6 years old. This was expected though, everyone says it tastes like toothpaste, and I know all of you hate brushing your teeth.
Cookies and Cream absolutely destroyed Superman 16-1. Sweatshirt and I may remain the only people to have ever touched Superman ice cream in our lives.
Chocolate moves on after beating Salted Carmel 11-6. Same thing for Vanilla, don’t be surprised if we end up with a Vanilla vs Chocolate finals.
The closest matchup of the entire first round would see Rocky Road just barely beating Strawberry 9-8, this one was expected to be the first of the big three to fall anyways.
The Voting Form can be found here
The Bracket can be found here
EggsThink’s Rankings
- Black Cherry
- Strawberry
- Salted Carmel
9. Butter Pecan
11. Peanut Butter
12. Mint Chocolate Chip
15. Superman
16. Coffee
AboveAverageJoe’s Rankings
5. Mint Chocolate Chip
6. Coffee
9. Salted Carmel
11. Butter Pecan
12. Strawberry
13. Peanut Butter
15. Black Cherry
16. Superman
Sweatshirt’s Rankings
- Superman
9. Strawberry
10. Black Cherry
12. Mint Chocolate Chip
13. Coffee
14. Butter Pecan
15. Salted Carmel
16. Peanut Butter
Hammy’s Rankings
- Strawberry
8. Coffee
10. Mint Chocolate Chip
11. Black Cherry
13. Peanut Butter
14. Salted Carmel
15. Butter Pecan
16. Superman

